SpellingJoy Icon

Best Prodigy Alternatives in 2025

Love Prodigy but want options? We compare the best math games and learning apps as alternatives to Prodigy Math.

SpellingJoy TeamSpellingJoy Team
•Last Updated: December 13, 2025
Kids playing educational games

Prodigy is wildly popular—and for good reason. Its RPG-style gameplay motivates millions of kids to practice math. But it's not perfect: the constant membership prompts can annoy, and it focuses on practice rather than teaching new concepts.

Whether you want deeper instruction (DreamBox), real-time competition (Mathletics), pure game-based learning (DragonBox), or free curriculum (Zearn), these alternatives offer different approaches to making math engaging.

Our Top Picks:

1

DreamBox

DreamBox is an adaptive K–8 math program that provides rigorous and personalized instruction using interactive visuals and intelligent scaffolding. Widely used in schools and homes.

Visit DreamBox
Visit Site
Best for - Adaptive instruction vs just practice
Price - $12.95/mo
Grades - K-8
Platforms - Web, iOS

Pros

  • ✓ Personalized learning adapts in real time
  • ✓ Strong visual and conceptual explanations
  • ✓ Aligned with Common Core and state standards

Cons

  • ✗ Premium pricing
  • ✗ Can be overwhelming for some younger students
2

Mathletics

Mathletics is an online platform offering curriculum-aligned math practice and live competitive games. Widely used in schools around the world.

Visit Mathletics
Visit Site
Best for - Live multiplayer math competitions
Price - $99/yr
Grades - K-12
Platforms - Web, iOS, Android

Pros

  • ✓ Live competitions and global rankings
  • ✓ Curriculum-aligned content
  • ✓ Detailed reporting for educators

Cons

  • ✗ Pricey for families
  • ✗ Can feel repetitive
3

Zearn

Zearn is a standards-aligned digital math platform offering comprehensive instruction, practice, and remediation. Free for families, premium for schools.

Visit Zearn
Visit Site
Best for - Free curriculum-aligned lessons
Price - Free (core)
Grades - K-8
Platforms - Web

Pros

  • ✓ Full curriculum for grades K–8
  • ✓ Free access for individuals
  • ✓ Embedded instruction and practice

Cons

  • ✗ Requires stable internet
  • ✗ Interface can feel clinical
4

DragonBox

DragonBox offers a suite of playful, conceptual math games for kids ages 4–14. Apps teach algebra, numbers, geometry through intuitive gameplay.

Visit DragonBox
Visit Site
Best for - Conceptual math through pure gameplay
Price - $7.99-$24.99 (one-time)
Grades - K-9
Platforms - iOS, Android

Pros

  • ✓ Highly engaging game-based learning
  • ✓ Focuses on number sense and algebra
  • ✓ Strong conceptual teaching

Cons

  • ✗ Limited content per app
  • ✗ No progress tracking
5

IXL

IXL is a comprehensive adaptive learning platform covering all subjects from Pre-K through 12th grade.

Visit IXL
Visit Site
Best for - Thorough skill coverage Pre-K to 12
Price - $79-159/yr
Grades - Pre-K-12
Platforms - Web, iOS, Android

Pros

  • ✓ Comprehensive K-12 coverage
  • ✓ Adaptive learning
  • ✓ Detailed analytics

Cons

  • ✗ Expensive
  • ✗ Spelling is small part of ELA
6

SplashLearn

SplashLearn offers game-based math and ELA practice for Pre-K through 5th grade. Known for engaging gameplay that keeps kids motivated.

Visit SplashLearn
Visit Site
Best for - Engaging games for Pre-K to 5
Price - $80/yr
Grades - Pre-K-5
Platforms - Web, iOS, Android

Pros

  • ✓ Strong math AND reading content
  • ✓ Game-based learning kids love
  • ✓ Personalized learning paths

Cons

  • ✗ Premium features require subscription
  • ✗ Reading is newer than math content
  • ✗ Can be addictive for some kids
7

Mathseeds

Mathseeds teaches foundational math skills through animated lessons, games, and quizzes for early learners. Part of the Reading Eggs ecosystem.

Visit Mathseeds
Visit Site
Best for - Gamified K-3 math curriculum
Price - $89/yr (with Reading Eggs)
Grades - K-3
Platforms - Web, iOS, Android

Pros

  • ✓ Fun, colorful interface
  • ✓ Aligned with Common Core
  • ✓ Rewards-based progression

Cons

  • ✗ Requires full subscription
  • ✗ Not ideal beyond grade 3
8

Elephant Learning

Elephant Learning is a data-driven math platform that builds conceptual understanding quickly through tailored exercises. Popular among homeschoolers.

Visit Elephant Learning
Visit Site
Best for - Data-driven math acceleration
Price - $35/mo
Grades - PreK-8
Platforms - Web

Pros

  • ✓ Claims "1 year of math in 3 months"
  • ✓ Detailed reporting and analytics
  • ✓ Custom learning paths

Cons

  • ✗ No free tier
  • ✗ Interface lacks modern polish
  • ✗ Premium pricing

Frequently Asked Questions

While Prodigy is excellent for practice, some parents find the membership upselling distracting, or want apps that teach concepts rather than just drill them. Alternatives like DreamBox offer deeper instruction, while Mathletics provides real-time competition.

Our Verdict

For actual instruction: DreamBox teaches concepts with adaptive visual lessons—Prodigy mainly drills what kids already know.

For competition: Mathletics offers live multiplayer math battles with global rankings—more direct competition than Prodigy's async battles.

For pure games: DragonBox teaches math through gameplay mechanics without explicit "math problems"—kids learn algebra without realizing it.

For free: Zearn offers a complete standards-aligned curriculum at no cost, with embedded instruction and practice.

Try SpellingJoy Free

About the Author

SpellingJoy Team

The SpellingJoy team is dedicated to creating free, high-quality spelling resources for K-6 students and their families. We test every app we review and provide honest assessments to help parents make informed decisions.

Related Articles

Best Math Apps for Kids

Full comparison

Best Free Math Apps

No cost options

DreamBox Alternatives

Adaptive math options